Cash Chiropractic Retention Guide

A free guide for cash-based chiropractors on measuring retention honestly, explaining care clearly, rebooking, following up and offering wellness care, without chasing a number or pressuring patients.

What you will learn

Retention is not about keeping every patient forever. It is about making sure the patients who would benefit from more care do not slip away because of a missed call, a confusing plan or a price surprise.

01

PVA, explained

Patient visit average is the most quoted retention number in chiropractic. It is simple to calculate and easy to misuse.

Trade press and coaches agree on the formula: PVA = total patient visits divided by new patients over the same period. It tells you, on average, how many visits each new patient turns into.

The guide walks through two examples:

  • Rick Wren's long-cited example (2001): 400 visits and 20 new patients in the same period gives a PVA of 20.
  • A rolling 12 months: 3,600 visits and 180 new patients gives 3,600 divided by 180 = 20. Each month, drop the oldest month, add the newest and recalculate. These are made-up numbers to show the arithmetic, not a benchmark.

Where people disagree is the window and who counts as a patient. Andrew Zacharia, writing for a software company, says a seven-day PVA is meaningless and recommends 3, 6 or 12 months, and The Chiro Tribune notes chiropractors calculate PVA inconsistently.

So the guide gives you one rule to follow: use one definition and never change it. Track total visits divided by new patients over a rolling 12 months (or 3 to 6 months if you are new), write down the window and your definition of “new patient,” and compare your clinic only with itself, month after month. Used that way, PVA becomes a useful trend line instead of a target.

In the guide: page 3

02

Why PVA benchmarks conflict

Search for a good PVA and you will find numbers from 12 to over 60. Here is why none of them make a reliable target.

Chiropractic Economics' self-selected Salary & Expense Surveys report average PVAs of 51.3 (2019), 58.1 (2020), 68 (2022), 60.3 (2023), 37 (2024) and 34 (2025). But applying the PVA formula to the same surveys' own weekly averages gives much lower numbers (the guide's arithmetic):

  • 2022: reported 68, recalculated about 14 (142 visits divided by 10 new patients)
  • 2023: reported 60.3, recalculated about 19
  • 2024: reported 37, recalculated about 11
  • 2025: reported 34, recalculated about 20

Other “standards” get the same scrutiny: Mark Sanna, DC's map of under 12 for pain relief, 12 to 24 functional and over 30 wellness is one coach's view with no validating data, and a “national average PVA is 16” claim in coach marketing gives no source. Andrew Zacharia's answer, that there is no valid benchmark, is called the most honest one found.

What patients actually do is better context. Gallup and Palmer polls found users averaged about 11 visits a year, and the top reason lapsed patients gave was that care worked (35%). A UK survey (MacPherson 2015, n=544) found a median of 6 visits in 12 months, and 59% of those who stopped said their problem improved. The takeaway: a drop-off is often a success.

In the guide: page 4

03

Better companion metrics

Use PVA as a secondary trend line. These four measures tell you more about where retention breaks, and what to fix.

The guide introduces four companion metrics:

  • Kept-appointment rate: completed visits divided by scheduled visits, times 100. It shows whether patients follow the plan they agreed to. Proposed by Christopher Colloca, DC, alongside days to next appointment, capacity use and revenue per visit and per hour.
  • Visit drop analysis: follow each new patient for 8 weeks, mark them active or inactive and record the visit number at which they stopped. Proposed by Moe Pisciottano, DC, of a coaching vendor.
  • Missed and cancelled %: missed plus cancelled visits divided by monthly visits. The Chiro Tribune flags anything above 15% as a front-desk communication problem.
  • Churn and reactivation: patients with no appointment in 3 months, net of new patients, which The Chiro Tribune says “should be negative every month.”

You also get a visit drop chart you can copy: shade the visit where each new patient stopped, and patterns appear after a few months. In Pisciottano's illustrative reading, early drops around visit 2 point to weak first-visit education or consultation, and drops around visits 6 to 7 point to weak reinforcement of progress. These are his interpretations, not measured rates. As The Chiro Tribune puts it (opinion): “The bank never asked about my PVA.”

In the guide: page 6

04

Where patients drop off

Patients do not usually decide to leave. They drift away at predictable points. Map your journey and put one fix at each point.

The guide maps seven steps in the patient journey, each with its own drop-off risk, adapted from Miles Bodzin, DC (opinion; his fixes map to products his company sells). Here is what can go wrong and what helps:

  • Books first visit: never arrives. Use easy online booking, a confirmation with what to expect, reminders and intake forms done at home.
  • Exam and consult: does not come back to hear results. Book the report of findings before they leave the first visit.
  • Report of findings: no clear plan or cost. Have the plan, goals, re-exam point and costs ready in writing.
  • Plan decision: says no, or yes without understanding. Offer real options, including pay per visit, and no pressure.
  • Active care: misses visits, then disappears. Book the next visit at checkout and follow up the same day after a missed visit.
  • Re-exam: cannot see progress. Repeat the same outcome measures and show the change.
  • Discharge or wellness: feels pushed. Offer wellness care to patients likely to benefit, as a choice. A “no” here can be a fine outcome.

Lapsed patients loop back through reactivation into a fresh exam and report of findings. Ryan Kain's advice (opinion) sums it up: “Stop trying to sell patients, and just explain in a clear and succinct way.”

In the guide: page 7

05

Report of findings and clear plans

Most expectation gaps are communication gaps. A clear report of findings, with costs, is the most evidence-aligned retention habit.

The UK patient survey (MacPherson 2015) shows the gap: 86% of patients expected the cost to be explained at the first visit, 71% knew little about possible reactions to treatment before starting and 58% knew little about what treatment involved. About 20% had unexpected or unpleasant reactions such as extra pain or fatigue, none serious, and the authors blamed mostly “poor or limited communication.” In the US, 18% of adults unlikely to see a DC said they “don't know what to expect” (Gallup-Palmer 2016).

A clear report of findings covers six things:

  • What you found: findings and working diagnosis, in plain words.
  • What care involves: the treatment you recommend and why, plus reasonable alternatives, including no care.
  • What to expect: likely benefits, possible reactions such as soreness or fatigue, and what to do if they happen.
  • Goals and checkpoints: measurable goals, recommended visit frequency and when you will re-examine.
  • Total cost and options: per-visit price, any package, how payment works, the refund policy and a Good Faith Estimate for self-pay patients when required.
  • Their choice: invite questions and make it clear they can decide later, choose fewer visits or pay per visit.

A one-view plan sheet lays out relief, corrective or rehab, and optional wellness phases with visits, goals, re-exam points and cost.

In the guide: page 8

06

Rebooking and re-exams

The easiest visit to keep is the one already on the calendar. Rebook before patients leave, and give progress a date.

Four rebooking habits at checkout:

  • Same time, every time: Mark Sanna, DC recommends recurring same-time slots, such as “every second Tuesday at 10 a.m.,” plus cluster booking and pre-scheduled wellness visits.
  • Book the plan, not one visit: Holly Jensen says the assistant schedules the accepted plan but cannot change frequency, because that is the doctor's clinical decision.
  • Make up missed visits fast: Jensen's rule is to make up a missed visit within the same week.
  • Let patients self-serve with online scheduling and two-way texting.

An example checkout script (not from a source) shows how to offer a specific time while leaving the choice with the patient.

On re-exams, coaches agree they “fall through the cracks,” and Jensen has assistants flag when one is due. The guide found no evidence-based re-exam interval, so set the cadence by clinical judgment and write it into each plan. At each re-exam, repeat the baseline measures (pain scale, function questionnaire, range of motion), show the change side by side, agree the next step and update the written plan and costs. Avoid fixed rules copied from a coach (no source supports “every 12 visits” or “every 30 days”), routine repeat X-rays without a clinical reason and re-exams used as a sales meeting.

In the guide: page 10

07

Missed visits and reactivation

A missed visit is the earliest warning sign. A kind, quick, consistent follow-up keeps most of them from turning into a lost patient.

The guide shares the most concrete system it found, from chiropractic assistant trainer Lisa Bilodeau (2008, opinion), citing Sherry Hodge's “Scripts for Success”:

  • Call within 20 minutes of the missed time and aim to rebook the same day.
  • No blame words: avoid “missed.” Try: “We had you down for 3 o'clock and wanted to make sure you're OK.”
  • Log every attempt in the record or a follow-up list, so nothing depends on memory.
  • Two tries, then the doctor: at most two calls, on different days and times. Then the doctor decides on a release letter, a “We missed you” card, a future call date or closing the file.

Reactivation should be an open door, not a hard sell. Sanna recommends welcoming lapsed patients back with a fresh exam, report of findings and plan, and letting them “know your door is always open.” Remember that many lapsed patients left because care worked, so ask why they stopped, and listen.

A simple schedule: at 3 months with no appointment, the front desk sends a short, personal check-in; when they reply or book, the doctor does a fresh exam rather than restarting an old plan; and every month the owner counts patients with no appointment in 3 months and how many came back.

In the guide: page 11

08

Wellness and maintenance care

There is real evidence for planned ongoing care, and it is specific: selected patients, a specific condition, a modest extra number of visits.

The guide explains the Nordic Maintenance Care trial (Eklund et al., PLoS ONE 2018). In this randomized trial, 328 Swedish patients with recurrent or persistent low back pain who responded well to initial care were assigned to planned maintenance care or to care only when symptoms returned. Maintenance care meant about 12.8 fewer days with bothersome pain over a year, at a cost of about 1.7 more treatments, with no serious adverse events. The authors recommend it “for selected patients.”

What the trial supports and what it does not:

  • Supports: offering maintenance care to early responders with recurrent or persistent low back pain, explaining the trade-off honestly (fewer bad days for a few extra visits a year) and letting patients choose.
  • Does not support: blanket wellness plans for every patient, claims for other conditions or promises of results. Quote the point estimates only, because the abstract's confidence interval for treatments looks inconsistent.

Saying “you are doing well, here is how to stay well, and you are welcome back anytime” is good retention too. The chapter ends with a Medicare note: Medicare does not cover maintenance therapy, it must not be billed as active care (no AT modifier), the Advance Beneficiary Notice process applies when an active-care service may be denied, and chiropractors cannot opt out of Medicare.

In the guide: page 12

09

Memberships and prepaid plans

Packages and memberships can make care simpler and more affordable. They also carry the most legal risk in a cash practice.

Prepayment can look like insurance: a 1995 National Association of Insurance Commissioners bulletin concluded that providers who accept prepayment can be “engaged in the business of insurance.” The guide summarizes four state examples:

  • Oregon (OAR 811-015-0002): written fees, services and time frame; no guarantee of results; a plainly labeled refund policy with a refund table.
  • Ohio (OAC 4734-9-11): a signed, dated and witnessed written plan; unused funds refunded within 14 business days; no plan longer than 12 months.
  • Texas (22 TAC §75.5): cancellable by either party at any time without penalty, with a pro rata refund.
  • Illinois (ICS legal counsel, 2022): prepayment “may require insurance licensure”; accept it only after examining and diagnosing.

A worked Illinois refund example: a patient prepays $1,000 at a quoted $30 per visit and uses 10 visits ($300), so the refund due is $700.

The common ground: offer a plan only after an exam and diagnosis, put it in writing, promise no results, include a plain refund policy calculated at the quoted rate, let patients cancel, keep plans finite and always offer pay per visit. Whether a monthly membership counts as insurance was not answered by any source, so check with your state board and insurance regulator and have a health care attorney review your documents.

In the guide: page 13

10

Ethics: care first

Retention done right is a by-product of good care and clear communication. The profession's own code sets the guardrails.

The guide quotes four principles from the American Chiropractic Association Code of Ethics (2023):

  • Patient first: “A doctor of chiropractic's primary responsibility, first and foremost, is for the benefit of the patient.”
  • Informed choice: enable “the patient to make an informed choice regarding proposed treatment options.”
  • No false expectations: do not mislead patients into “false or unjustified expectations of the results of treatment.”
  • No exploiting trust: do not exploit “the trust and dependency of the patient.”

The code has no specific clause on fees or prepaid plans. Stephen Perle, DC (anecdotal) describes a consultant who criticized his clinical judgment because his PVA was low: “One can't make clinical decisions based upon policy that's purely money-driven.”

A clear do and don't list follows. Do base frequency on findings, goals and re-exams, show per-visit prices next to any package, let patients choose fewer visits or stop, discharge patients who met their goals and track PVA as a trend. Don't set PVA or visit-count targets for staff, ask for long commitments or prepayment before an exam, use scarcity or fear scripts, order routine repeat X-rays to drive visits or let a coach's script override clinical judgment.

In the guide: page 15

11

Patient voices

What patients say when they feel pressured, and when they do not. Small samples, skewed toward skeptics, but a consistent pattern.

The guide shares individual posts from public forums, each labeled anecdotal:

  • “When you are in so much pain, you will sign anything to make the pain stop!” A poster whose husband was asked to choose a 6- or 12-month plan before treatment.
  • “Would never force the issue.” Another poster, describing a chiropractor who offered plans as optional savings, which posters said was fine.
  • “Keeps pushing me to do more sessions.” A first-time patient asked to come about three times a week while “struggling financially” (r/Olathe, July 2024).
  • Hugh Crozier, DC (New Zealand, 2023) opposes prescriptive care plans and describes a patient pressured to prepay $2,000 for visits that did not fit her schedule and did not help.

National context from Gallup-Palmer 2016 shows why some US adults are unlikely to see a chiropractor: prefer another provider (33%), distrust (29%), safety concerns (23%), too many visits (19%), don't know what to expect (18%) and too expensive (only 10%).

The lesson: the trigger is commitment before trust. Clear per-visit prices, optional packages, re-exam checkpoints and an easy refund answer most of these complaints.

In the guide: page 16

12

Checklist and KPI sheet

Print this chapter. Work through the checklist once, then fill in the KPI sheet every month.

The retention checklist has four groups:

  • Measure: write down your PVA definition, window and new patient rule; track kept-appointment rate and missed and cancelled % monthly; run a visit drop chart for every new patient; count patients with no appointment in 3 months.
  • First visit and plan: intake forms done before the first visit, report of findings booked before the patient leaves, a written plan with goals, re-exam point and total cost, a per-visit option next to any package and a Good Faith Estimate when required.
  • Active care: next visit booked at checkout, reminders on for every appointment, missed visits followed up the same day (max two tries), re-exams flagged in advance and the same outcome measures repeated.
  • After care: a discharge conversation when goals are met, wellness offered as a choice to likely responders, a recall message at 3 months, prepaid plans checked against state rules and no visit-count targets for doctors or staff.

The 12-month KPI tracking sheet covers volume (new patients, total visits, rolling PVA), plan follow-through (scheduled and kept visits, kept-appointment rate, missed and cancelled %) and drop-off and return (early and mid-plan drops, no appointment in 3 months, reactivated patients and net churn, where you aim for negative). Compare each number with your own past months, not with someone else's practice.

In the guide: page 18

13

Key terms and FAQ

Plain-English definitions and answers to the retention questions chiropractors ask most.

The key terms section explains PVA, kept-appointment rate, visit drop analysis, churn, report of findings (ROF), maintenance (wellness) care and prepaid plan. The FAQ answers:

  • What is a good PVA for a chiropractor? There is no validated benchmark; track your own PVA over a fixed rolling window and watch the trend.
  • How do you calculate PVA? Total patient visits divided by new patients over the same period, for example 400 visits divided by 20 new patients = PVA 20.
  • Is maintenance chiropractic care evidence-based? For selected patients, yes: about 12.8 fewer days with bothersome pain a year for about 1.7 more treatments.
  • Are chiropractic prepaid plans legal? It depends on the state; Oregon, Ohio and Texas set specific rules, and Illinois counsel warns prepayment may require insurance licensure.
  • Why do chiropractic patients stop coming? Most often because they got better: 59% in a UK survey. Unclear plans, costs and pressure also drive drop-off.

Every answer is backed by the guide's 35 numbered sources, checked at the time of writing, with coach, vendor and forum sources labeled in the text.

In the guide: page 20

Cover of Cash Chiropractic Retention Guide, a free Ruana guide

Get the free guide

How cash-based chiropractors measure retention honestly, explain care clearly, rebook, follow up and offer wellness care.

PDF · 25 pages · Free. Sent straight to your inbox.

After you click, check your inbox and confirm your email. Your guide arrives right after.

100% free. We never share your email, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Key facts from the guide

A few of the numbers inside, each from a named source. Vendor data is labeled as vendor data.

~11

visits a year, on average, among US adults who saw a chiropractor.

Source: Gallup and Palmer College, 2015 and 2017

35%

of lapsed patients gave the top reason for not returning: “care was effective and I no longer need it”.

Source: Palmer-Gallup Annual Report, 2017

59%

of UK patients who stopped care said it was because their problem improved. Only 5% said they could not afford it.

Source: MacPherson et al., 2015 (n=544)

6

visits in 12 months was the median in a UK survey of chiropractic patients.

Source: MacPherson et al., 2015 (n=544)

12.8

fewer days with bothersome back pain a year with maintenance care, in selected early responders, at a cost of about 1.7 more treatments.

Source: Eklund et al., PLoS ONE, 2018

34

average PVA reported in the self-selected 2025 survey, against 68 in 2022. The guide shows why these numbers do not add up.

Source: Chiropractic Economics, 2025

General information for practitioners in the United States, not legal, tax or financial advice. Figures were checked at the time of writing; rules and prices change, so confirm with the source.

Page 20 of Cash Chiropractic Retention GuidePage 9 of Cash Chiropractic Retention Guide

Inside the guide: A checklist and KPI sheet you can use on Monday

The guide starts with the patient visit average (PVA) and why it works best as a trend line, not a target, then walks through the patient journey, where people drop off, and the habits that keep the right patients coming back. It ends with a checklist and KPI tracking sheet.

PDF · 25 pages · Free

Frequently asked questions

Answers from the Key terms and FAQ chapter of the guide.

What is a good PVA for a chiropractor?

There is no validated benchmark. Published survey averages conflict and cannot be reproduced from the same surveys’ own weekly numbers. Track your own PVA over a fixed rolling window and watch the trend.

How do you calculate PVA?

Divide total patient visits by new patients over the same period. Example: 400 visits divided by 20 new patients = PVA 20. Use a rolling 12 months (or 3 to 6) and keep the definition fixed.

Is maintenance chiropractic care evidence-based?

For selected patients, yes. A 2018 randomized trial found maintenance care gave early responders with recurrent or persistent low back pain about 12.8 fewer days with bothersome pain a year, for about 1.7 more treatments.

Are chiropractic prepaid plans legal?

It depends on the state. Oregon, Ohio and Texas set specific rules (written plans, refunds, cancellation, time limits), and Illinois counsel warns prepayment may require insurance licensure. Check your board and insurance regulator.

Why do chiropractic patients stop coming?

Most often because they got better. In a UK survey, 59% of patients who stopped said their problem improved. Unclear plans, costs and pressure also drive drop-off.

Keep the right patients on schedule with Ruana

Book the next visit before patients leave, let them reschedule online 24/7, and send automated email and SMS reminders so missed visits do not quietly turn into lost patients.

  • Online booking, 24/7
  • Automated email & SMS reminders
  • Deposits at booking
  • Payment links for invoices
  • Online intake forms with e-signature
  • Advanced SOAP Notes
  • Invoices, receipts & superbills
  • Supports HIPAA & GDPR compliance
01

Patients book online

Booking runs 24/7, with automated email and SMS reminders before every visit.

02

Intake done before the visit

Intake forms with e-signature go out at booking and are saved to the record.

03

Notes with Advanced SOAP Notes

Custom buttons write your common findings and treatments into the note in one click.

Ready to stop losing patients to missed visits?

Online booking, reminders and Advanced SOAP Notes in one place. Start your free 14-day trial now.

14-day free trial, no credit card.